Сравнение голосовых помощников: Siri, Google, Alexa, Bixby

This review compares four popular voice assistants: Apple Siri, Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, and Samsung Bixby, evaluating their functionality based on 65 carefully selected questions.

Basic Math and Smart Home Control

Basic mathematical tasks (2 + 2 — 1, 104 + 64 * 14 / 3 * 7, unit conversions, bill splitting) were successfully handled by all assistants. Control of smart devices, such as turning off a smart lightbulb with the command «Turn off the light,» was also successful for all, assuming device compatibility.

Advanced Device Control and Smart Doorbell Interaction

More complex device controls (disabling Bluetooth, adjusting screen brightness, changing wallpaper, activating dark mode, taking a selfie) were tested. Alexa underperformed in this test. Google Assistant demonstrated superior battery level reporting. Google Assistant, Bixby, and Alexa successfully displayed images from a smart doorbell; Siri lacked Ring Doorbell support.

Internet Queries and Smart Plug Control

The assistants’ ability to answer internet queries (weather forecasts, song identification, biographical information, movie details, recipe searches) was evaluated. All assistants successfully controlled smart plugs to boil water (via a smart kettle).

App Control and Smart Vacuum Cleaner Management

Control of third-party applications (opening the App Store, setting alarms, viewing photos, calculating distances, route planning, playing music and video) was tested. Google Assistant, Bixby, and Alexa successfully controlled a smart vacuum cleaner to clean a specific room (kitchen), unlike Siri.

Advanced Commands and «Human Factor»

This section tested complex commands (sending emails, searching eBay, translation, text-to-speech, contact creation, messaging, input switching, emoji addition, call ending). The «human factor» — natural interaction — was also assessed (name memorization, storytelling, information retention and forgetting).

Routines and Automation

Finally, routines were tested: automated series of actions triggered by a single command. Location-based routines (arriving home) and Bluetooth-triggered routines (car connectivity) were evaluated. Bixby excelled, including management of bad habits (e.g., limiting game time).

Conclusion

Google Assistant emerged as the winner in this voice assistant comparison.

Что будем искать? Например,Переговоры